Migrant tales
Menu
  • #MakeRacismHistory “In Your Eyes”
  • About Migrant Tales
  • It’s all about Human Rights
  • Literary
  • Migrant Tales Media Monitoring
  • NoHateFinland.org
  • Tales from Europe
Menu

Separating urban myths from facts in the Finnish immigration debate

Posted on October 24, 2011 by Migrant Tales

By Enrique Tessieri

To confirm whether anti-immigrant politicians are spreading urban myths or not, I recommend taking a look at the 2010 Finnish Immigration Service (FIS) annual report. What you may find may startle, even anger you.

I’m not speaking specifically of Perussuomalaiset (PS) party MPs like Teuvo Hakkarainen, who are walking political time bombs packed with ignorance. The source of your irritation may be more credible politicians who should know better but are spreading and enforcing urban myths about immigrants in their opportunistic bid to gain votes.

There is nothing “patriotic” about spreading urban myths about immigrants because great harm is done to Finland economically, socially and politically.

If you look at last year’s FIS report, we will see some startling facts that blow the cover off the urban myths that are fed like “facts” to the public by some politicians. Here it is (and it does not harm to repeat this fact over again): The main reason why foreigners moved to Finland in 2010 was for family reasons (31%), study (25%) and work (17%). Asylum seekers accounted for  only 10%.

While these figures attempt to give a clean-cut division of the reasons for coming to Finland, the issue is a bit more complex. Just because a person come to Finland due to family reasons, he can end up employed like the ones that came for work.

What does a mere 17% (3,030 people) of foreigners who got work permits last year on the grounds of employment and self-employment tell us?

For one, it reveals that too few skilled people move on their own will to Finland for work. It tells us as well another disturbing fact: We are far behind other countries in attracting skilled labor as our ever-growing army of pensioners swells this decade and the next.

While some politicians warned us in 2006 that the entire Estonian workforce, or half a million people, was ready to invade Finland, the truth is that we are no magnet for skilled labor.

Why would a skilled immigrant move with his or her family to Finland if there are easier and friendlier countries in Europe? Why would they move to a country where a right-wing populist anti-immigration party, the PS, gained 19.1% of the votes in April from 4.05% in 2007?

Why would a foreign company invest in this country and create more jobs?

While the recession may be an important factor why there were 25.2% less permits given to foreigners compared with 2009 for work and self-employment, other factors like the weather, high taxation, language certainly play a role.

What to do?

Send each politician an electronic copy of the FIS annual report and ask them why they distort the facts in order to hide the real issues, which is dealing with our ever-growing demographic challenges.

Note: There are other urban myths that I could have brought up. These can be discussed as well.

Category: All categories, Enrique

32 thoughts on “Separating urban myths from facts in the Finnish immigration debate”

  1. Mark says:
    October 24, 2011 at 7:40 am

    Enrique

    Nice to see the FIS report for 2010 has come out. Interesting take that you have on the report.

    However, as a reader, I’m left wondering what the ‘myths’ and ‘distortion of facts’ that you speak of actually are, because you do not detail them or compare them directly to the data from the report. The only idea that you do speak of is the ‘invasion of Estonians’, but that cannot be all of it.

    It would be very useful to see exactly what quotes from which politicians you think are directly contradicted by which pieces of information from the report. While this is more work, it would definitely make this a more valuable article to add to your commendable blog.

    Reply
    1. Enrique says:
      October 24, 2011 at 8:36 am

      Hi Mark, the myth is the following: We are all speaking of the threat of immigration and how everyone is ready to invade Finland. This could not be further from the truth. We have to START marketing our country in order to attract skilled labor.

      Reply
  2. Mark says:
    October 24, 2011 at 8:47 am

    Enrique

    But if the debate is about people coming to Finland and not being able to be productive citizens, this report adds more weight to that argument, not less, because number of people arriving ‘for work’ has diminished as a proportion. However, proportions are misleading, real numbers would be more useful.

    Also, the number of people coming for ‘family reasons’ can also be misleading. I came to Finland for ‘family reaons’, but ended up working after two weeks and have never claimed unemployment benefit. Does this refer to family reunification, or what?

    My point was also that you refer to politicians distorting the picture, but don’t give direct quotes. That’s okay, but that means we have to take your word for it. No I’m sure you have relevant quotes in mind, but it’s just better for me, as a reader, to know what those are, because I’m not reading the Finnish news, for example.

    No disrespect, just an honest reaction.

    Reply
  3. justicedemon says:
    October 24, 2011 at 9:17 am

    Ricky

    The FIS annual report describes the work of a specialist agency from its own specialist point of view. The figures that you quote must be understood in terms of the underlying system, which is by no means simple.

    You are making the very basic and common error of assuming that the grounds for admission are the only reason for arriving and remaining. The 17 per cent figure for permits issued on grounds of work only represents relatively recent arrivals of third country nationals where there were no other grounds for issuing a permit. It does not follow from this that 17 per cent of foreigners moving to Finland in 2010 did so for work alone.

    You cannot interpret these figures without a full appreciation of the underlying immigration management system and a qualitative understanding of the circumstances of newly arrived immigrants. Points of the kind made by Mark in his second paragraph above are relevant not least because of the structure of the immigration system and the feedback effect on immigrant behaviour.

    Reply
    1. Enrique says:
      October 24, 2011 at 10:10 am

      JusticeDemon and Mark, so what you guys are stating is that these figures only give a partial picture. Ok, granted, and I understand Marks’ point. Does it mean that those that come to Finland for which reason it may be end up in the labor market?

      My point here is that few immigrants are granted residence permits due to work. It’s mostly through family and students. That was my point. However, I consider Mark’s and JusticeDemon’s point valid in order to give a more comprehensive view of the situation, which I have added on the blog entry.

      Reply
  4. Johnny says:
    October 24, 2011 at 9:23 am

    The thing is, many of the people who move for “family reasons” are technically the same as asylum seekers (mainly from Africa) – and thus “not productive”. That statistic is very distorted already due to different classifications being used. Also, about attracting “skilled workers”, the skilled workers are pulled in by companies who actually need them. Finland does not need mass workers as such in the current situation, but of course some companies need specific expertise.

    Reply
    1. Enrique says:
      October 24, 2011 at 10:34 am

      Hi Johnny and welcome to Migrant Tales. How do you know if an immigrant from a certain region is automatically “not productive” as you mentioned? Immigrants are productive and offer services from low to highly skilled. If we speak of workers, look at the bus drivers in Helsinki. Who would drive your buses if immigrants would not?

      Moreover, I don’t believe Finland will be a magnet for the highly skilled immigrants because there are more attractive countries. They may stay in Finland for a few years but there aim is probably to move on the a country like the United States or elsewhere. So maybe we are looking in the future at middle-skilled workers.

      Reply
  5. sirianita says:
    October 24, 2011 at 10:57 am

    Important information, next I would like to read something about the racist/fascist beliefs many Finnish people harbor without realized that those are their beliefs as living in a homogenous society often allows the growth of such beliefs/attitudes as part of its natural character and is often identified as “love for your country and your people”. Finland is a difficult place to live in, I would guess that given a choice many of the foreigners who are interested in work or asylum would prefer to be somewhere else given the opportunity; an idea that many Finns would find hard to believe as they believe Finland it the greatest place ever to live in.

    Reply
  6. Johnny says:
    October 24, 2011 at 10:57 am

    Thanks, Enrique.
    About being “productive”, that was a reference to an earlier text. However, I invite you to take a look at the employment rates of different (source) nationalities here in Finland as well. That should provide you with some additional information you might find useful when discussing “productivity”. “Immigrants are productive” is just an another generalization which is not useful by any means. Please do not place all immigrants under a same title. And that bus driver comment is an another all too common generalization. Please check out the different (source) nationalities of the drivers as well. Certain nationalities/areas are not represented in the drivers anyhow. The bus companies are trying to find cheap labor and immigrants are often just that. That is a problem as well.

    As of now, Finland does not need to be a “magnet” for any immigrants. There are too many unemployed, talented people here (from different countries as well) already and those should be taken care first for many reasons.

    Reply
  7. Mark says:
    October 24, 2011 at 11:09 am

    Okay. So people who criticize immigration figures because they show people are not here ‘for work’ are ignoring that there are other perfectly legitimate reasons, i.e. studying or looking after their families?

    I think you should do another article that explores the relevance and problems with the data in this report. it would be very useful. i think you could then link that back to actual quotes and criticisms made by Finnish politicians. That kind of thorough analysis would give great credibility to the valid points you are trying to make.

    Reply
  8. justicedemon says:
    October 24, 2011 at 11:31 am

    Johnny

    The bus companies are trying to find cheap labor and immigrants are often just that.

    The legally enforceable minimum pay rate for PSV drivers is based on collective bargaining between the Finnish Federation of Road Transport Employers and the Finnish Transport Workers’ Union AKT. You are either suggesting that these Finnish organisations are conspiring in a cheap labour scam or that public transport companies are operating illegally by not honouring the agreement. In either case it would be nice to see your evidence.

    The plain fact is that there is a long-sustained labour shortage in the PSV sector. If that bothers you greatly, then you should change your present job and start working as a bus driver.

    Reply
  9. justicedemon says:
    October 24, 2011 at 11:50 am

    Ricky

    The problem is that without understanding the system that creates those permit statistics, there is no way to interpret them for any purpose other than administering the immigration management system. You are attempting to draw conclusions from the permit statistics as if they were the findings of a survey investigating why people came to Finland. They are not.

    There is an obvious analogy with shopping. An analysis of sales at Stockmann might show that 3 per cent of customers buy shoes, but it does not follow from this that those customers came into Stockmann solely or even primarily to buy shoes, still less that the desire to buy shoes can be viewed as a necessary and sufficient condition for coming into Stockmann.

    The most obvious example of this confusion is the familiar assertion that “the reason for immigration was marriage to a Finnish citizen”. This can never be a complete explanation, as it ignores the factors affecting the decision of a couple to choose Finland as their family home.

    Reply
  10. BlandaUpp says:
    October 24, 2011 at 12:17 pm

    @Johnny
    “However, I invite you to take a look at the employment rates of different (source) nationalities here in Finland as well. That should provide you with some additional information you might find useful when discussing “productivity”. ”

    Maybe we should block people coming from countries that have more unemployed people living here already than our national average. Is that a good starting point?

    Finnish 5183058 8.7% unemployment
    Russia 26909 27,8% unemployment
    Ukraine 1798 17.7% unemployment
    Lithuania 615 12.5% unemployment
    Bulgaria 618 12.2% unemployment
    Italy 1432 11.5% unemployment
    Poland 1888 11% unemployment
    Norway 695 10.8% unemployment
    Britain 3213 10.1% unemployment
    Nigeria 1020 10% unemployment
    Japan 905 9.6% unemployment
    Bangladesh 840 9.5% unemployment
    Ethiopia 651 8.2% unemployment
    Ghana 700 8% unemployment
    India 2736 7.2% unemployment
    China 4620 8.5% unemployment
    Kenya 640 4% unemployment

    Then we have refugees who in any society take at least a generation to adapt to their new country.

    Myanmar 1043 74,7% unemployment
    Sudan 1083 50,9% unemployment
    Afganistan 2189 61,0% unemployment
    Irak 3238 60,9% unemployment
    Somalia 4919 55,2% unemployment

    Source: http://www.stat.fi/til/tyokay/2008/01/tyokay_2008_01_2010-04-20_tau_001_fi.html

    Reply
  11. Risto says:
    October 24, 2011 at 1:20 pm

    “Why would they move to a country where a right-wing populist anti-immigration party, the PS, gained 19.1% of the votes in April from 4.05% in 2007?”

    Why would they move to … Belgium, Holland, France, Switzerland, Hungary, Italy, Austria, Denmark, and the list goes on. Really, I think the rise of populist and/ or racist political parties is an evolution which is going on throughout Europe.

    Whether this really stops people from moving to another country? I’m not so convinced.

    Reply
  12. Johnny says:
    October 24, 2011 at 1:58 pm

    Justicedemon wrote: “The legally enforceable minimum pay rate for PSV drivers is based on collective bargaining between the Finnish Federation of Road Transport Employers and the Finnish Transport Workers’ Union AKT. You are either suggesting that these Finnish organisations are conspiring in a cheap labour scam or that public transport companies are operating illegally by not honouring the agreement. In either case it would be nice to see your evidence.

    The plain fact is that there is a long-sustained labour shortage in the PSV sector. If that bothers you greatly, then you should change your present job and start working as a bus driver.”

    I am not suggesting either. I would find it nice if you did not draw any strange/false assumptions from a text which does not contain them, though. What I am saying is that the bus drivers are not getting paid enough for the job they are doing. That – and the general laziness of the Finnish people who technically get paid as much or more by just sitting home instead – is the reason the immigrants end up consisting of almost half of the number of the bus drivers in the Helsinki area, for example. The salary for the job (and also the fact that the same lazy Finns/immigrants who just sit home beat up the bus drivers now and then, if I may exaggerate a little here) – even if it is agreed by a union etc – is not a factor which would make people interested. It is not that hard to understand if you actually give it try.

    Reply
  13. justicedemon says:
    October 24, 2011 at 2:59 pm

    Johnny

    I responded to the simplistic equation that you originally suggested:

    The bus companies are trying to find cheap labor and immigrants are often just that.

    Now you have broadened the terms of reference and stopped talking about cheap labour. I’m sure that AKT would agree with you that bus drivers are not paid enough, and I assume that we can count on your support when the next public transport strike seeks to address this question. The employers, on the other hand, argue that the terms of competitive tendering of public transport services (specifically fare caps and local authority subsidy levels) prevent any wage increases. Assuming that this is not a barefaced lie by the employers (which would be hard to sustain in a publicly procured service), this comes down to the question of how much more local tax you are ready to pay or how much more you are willing to pay for your public transport tickets.

    Anyway, YOU are obviously not a lazy Finn or immigrant staying at home, so we return to the original point: why don’t YOU become a bus driver? If you have a better paid job, then I’m sure that we can find a diligent Finn or immigrant willing to take it, and we can all applaud your public spirited sacrifice every time we catch your bus.

    Reply
  14. Fawwaz Faris says:
    October 24, 2011 at 5:16 pm

    facts versus myths

    Reply
    1. Enrique says:
      October 24, 2011 at 7:07 pm

      Hi Fawwaz Faris and welcome to our blog, Migrant Tales. Facts versus myths is one of the greatest battles immigrants are engaging in to get greater acceptance. Those that spread urban myths are either to ignorant to know the difference or too sinister that know the difference.

      We hope to hear more of you. You have posted some beautiful pictures on your FB page.

      Reply
  15. Seppo says:
    October 24, 2011 at 9:53 pm

    “Why would a skilled immigrant move with his or her family to Finland if there are easier and friendlier countries in Europe?”

    Because they have a job waiting here. If there is not a job, then they don’t come, and that’s it.

    I think it is obvious that Finland can never ever entirely compete with lets say the US when it comes to attractiveness. So if there is a choice, the worker will go to the US. So far – and I don’t see this changing in the short term – there are more skilled workers looking to find a job abroad than there are those jobs for skilled foreign workers in different countries.

    Finland has an OK reputation (where it even has one, most people in this world don’t know much about Finland). I think if we ever need to import foreign workers en masse (which is not the case at the moment) we will be able to that. A more important question is whether or not these workers will decide to stay in Finland after a few years. Here something like the rise of the PS might have a negative effect.

    It is good to note that the weather and the high taxes (=good social network and services) is something that some people like about Finland. Yes, I know many people from southern Europe who prefer this climate to theirs. And I know even more immigrants who think our system with higher taxes and more social equality is better than the US one. These things we should see as assets, not as barriers. They might not attract the big masses but they will attract those people who are not only interested in going abroad but also specifically interested in going to a country like Finland. I have traveled enough in Eastern Europe in order to tell that there are a lot of them.

    Reply
  16. Johnny says:
    October 25, 2011 at 1:01 am

    Justicedemon wrote: “Now you have broadened the terms of reference and stopped talking about cheap labour.” (some general rambling cut off to make the text cleaner)
    Interesting how you refuse to admit that there are immigrants who are more willing to work for less pay than the “original Finns” and thus become “cheap labor”. What do you think you can gain by not admitting that fact?

    “Anyway, YOU are obviously not a lazy Finn or immigrant staying at home, so we return to the original point: why don’t YOU become a bus driver? If you have a better paid job, then I’m sure that we can find a diligent Finn or immigrant willing to take it, and we can all applaud your public spirited sacrifice every time we catch your bus.”
    How come is that an original point here? It was just one of the very general things to say for an argument’s sake by you, and that will lead to just pointless arguing. Anyhow, to make you able to write some more of the same, what do you think the society would gain if I switched jobs to a bus driver? And by the way, when you enter the workforce at some stage you will understand that not everyone is qualified for every job, so things just do not work like that in real life.

    Reply
  17. justicedemon says:
    October 25, 2011 at 8:09 am

    Johnny

    You cannot respond to my point, though, can you? Call it “general rambling” if you wish, but the pay rates for bus drivers are set in the standard way for Finland: by collective bargaining based on the economic and administrative realities of the sector concerned (local government licensing of public transport, competitive tendering for services and a cap on public subsidies). If you think the outcome of this entirely Finnish process is to create a cheap labour sector in the job market, then that is an entirely Finnish problem.

    You are evidently unwilling to do anything about this problem, such as paying higher local taxes or public transport fares, or enrolling on a PSV training course and changing your occupation. Instead you choose to slur immigrants for taking up the slack.

    It’s a simple equation. Without immigrants you would have no bus to ride unless you learned to drive it yourself, or paid more in taxes and fares.

    Reply
  18. Fredie says:
    October 25, 2011 at 8:47 am

    What wrong about cheap labor if it is legal, for many immigrants will work cheap payment that to stay at home doing nothing and put you down emotionally and mentally.
    That’s only stepping stone for much better future, working is not only for money but also principle of life, you work so you eat.

    Reply
    1. Enrique says:
      October 25, 2011 at 8:59 am

      Hi Fredle and welcome to Migrant Tales. Do you think it is right that a country accepts immigrants and does nothing to protect their rights? If we look at my former home state of California, things work in such a fashion. The state maintained its competitive edge with the help of immigrants and especially undocumented immigrants. Without them, the whole system would be cut from the knees. As you know, California is bankrupt but for other reasons.

      Reply
  19. Mark says:
    October 25, 2011 at 9:15 am

    Fredie

    Have you ever done low-skilled poorly paid work? It can actually be a hindrence to finding better work because you are spending the productive time of the day at the workplace and also making time for interviews without alerting your employer is also problematic. Also, that kind of work can sap your motivation and energy for looking for other work. Not only that, but it also skews the unemployment figures – as it’s often said, there are loads of jobs available for the unemployed (foreigners), when in fact, a good many of the applicants may be people in low-paid or part-time work trying to get an improved position.

    You do have a point, but it’s just not so straightfoward as you make out.

    Reply
  20. Fredie says:
    October 25, 2011 at 11:12 am

    Enrique and Mark, I wrote about cheap labor BUT LEGAL.
    I think we can’t generalize immigrants, as you know immigrants mean multitude of languages, cultures, religions, educated people and people hardly never been in the school. we suppose not to set high standard for those immigrants that can’t reach that those high standard, we know people become successful because of hard work and many of them start in zero. we are all individual if want to be slave doing cheap is your chose but if some want to progress and to move more forward than working as cheap labor.
    Mark, I worked as a volunteer for 16 years in one organization they just taking cared my basic needs but I love what I’m doing, maybe you don’t understand that.

    Reply
  21. Mark says:
    October 25, 2011 at 12:45 pm

    Fredie

    – “Mark, I worked as a volunteer for 16 years in one organization they just taking cared my basic needs but I love what I’m doing, maybe you don’t understand that.”

    Why wouldn’t I understand it? It sounds like you were quite happy to get a low remuneration for the work you were doing as a volunteer and that the benefit of doing the work for you was measured in more than simply monetary terms. I understand that and applaud your sense of values.

    – “Enrique and Mark, I wrote about cheap labor BUT LEGAL.”

    I’m sorry Freddie, but I didn’t quite understand where the ‘legality’ of the work comes into what I was talking about. Maybe that was something just for Enrique.

    I agree we cannot generalise about immigrants, and if I did do that, then thanks for pointing it out. I’m very much in favour of hearing about individual cases, simply because it gets us out of the habit of talking about immigrants as collectives and assuming that laws are easy ‘one-size-fits-all’ solutions to complex social problems.

    Reply
  22. Johnny says:
    October 27, 2011 at 10:50 am

    Justicedemon goes on again: “You are evidently unwilling to do anything about this problem, such as paying higher local taxes or public transport fares, or enrolling on a PSV training course and changing your occupation. Instead you choose to slur immigrants for taking up the slack.

    It’s a simple equation. Without immigrants you would have no bus to ride unless you learned to drive it yourself, or paid more in taxes and fares.”

    I really thought I could have a real discussion in this blog but unfortunately it seems that it is impossible. “You are evidently unwilling…” How is it “evident” that I refuse to pay higher local taxes or fares? Or “slur imigrants”? You seem to be extremely narrow-minded and bitter. Perhaps some growing up will fix that for you at some point. Blog owner, I am sorry, but I will not continue this conversation. I know I am not really “needed” here but I would have liked to take part in the conversation. Now it is just pointless if I get some crazy accusations by just writing a couple of messages.

    Reply
  23. Mark says:
    October 27, 2011 at 12:44 pm

    Johnny

    It’s great that you want to contribute, but throwaway comments and ill-thought out statements are likely to dump you in hot water. This is a very hotly contested issue, immigration, and so terms of reference need to be clearly defined, while stereotypical ideas about immigrants or issues that relate to them are likely to be challenged.

    Ironically, you stated quite usefully that generalisations are not helpful and then proceded in the very next sentence offered a cracking generalisation that tried to connect ‘cheap labour’ with immigrants, when in fact salaries are negotiated by Finns looking after the interests of a good many Finnish transport workers. JD pulled you up on it, and rather than admit, it was a little rash, who cares anyway, you tried belaboured the point, changed the terms of reference and tried to win a different battle with JD.

    I have to say, JD is not a bitter, small-minded person, as far as I have seen through his postings here. On the contrary, he thinks the issues through very careful, only speaks about those issues he genuinely knows about, (not always my strong point) and applies a fair and rational point of view. However, he does have a rather caustic and quite funny sarcasm when it comes to dealing with folks that make it personal against him.

    Reply
    1. Enrique says:
      October 27, 2011 at 1:32 pm

      –I have to say, JD is not a bitter, small-minded person, as far as I have seen through his postings here.

      I have to agree with Mark on this one. JD knows his facts and can debate an issue like immigration very well because he knows. He is an immigrant and has a lot of legal experience in this field, which is of great value to this blog.

      By the way, this blog has over 15,000 threads and I know that JD has been involved one way or another in most of these like me.

      Reply
  24. Johnny says:
    October 27, 2011 at 8:09 pm

    Interesting. OK, this will be my last message here. On the other hand I am glad to see that like-minded people stand up for each other, but I would appreciate if you would actually read the messages you are replying to. 🙂

    What I am saying and said is that:
    – The fact that in the capitol area about half of the bus drivers are immigrants is true.
    – The “original” Finns seem to be too lazy or greedy to become bus drivers for the current salary/benefits so therefore the bus companies find immigrants who will work for less for one reason or another.
    – The bus drivers are paid too little for their work, no matter the nationality or origin.
    – The bus companies, in my opinion, are exploiting the situation and can get away with paying too little for a job which is demanding.

    And this is bad because…? Am I “slurring” immigrants or making injust generalizations here in your opinion?

    And because I said the above (and pretty much nothing more of substance), in “JD’s” opinion I am not willing to pay more taxes, I not willing to pay more for the bus fare, and am a terrible person for not marching on the streets right now and really really suck because I am not giving up my current job and become a bus driver myself.

    OK. Have a nice day. 🙂

    Reply
  25. justicedemon says:
    October 27, 2011 at 10:23 pm

    Johnny

    Crash and burn.

    You are not the first commenter here to feign offence when your views are refuted. Plenty have come here to spew unfounded prejudices and then run away whelping like a spanked puppy when those prejudices are exposed, just as you are doing now.

    Your last contribution changes the terms of reference once again, but the fact remains that immigrant bus drivers are working for the pay rates set by national collective bargaining between the competent employers’ federation (ALT) and the transport workers’ union (AKT). The latter organisation is hardly a pushover in wage negotiations and has been quite willing to threaten and take industrial action over the years in order to demonstrate its resolve. There is no evidence that public transport companies are making exorbitant profits in Finland, where the overall financial framework is based on local authority route licensing, competitive tendering and subsidies (in other words, the finances are transparent). It follows from these facts that if PSV driving is a low wage occupation, then this is a direct outcome of Finnish public transport policy.

    There is, in particular, no evidence to support your view that transport companies are exploiting any “situation”. Their minimum labour costs are determined in the same way as in most industries and form part of the framework within which they submit their bids for the right to operate services. Those costs are known to the local authorities and cannot be substantially exaggerated as a component of a bid, even if the transport companies seek to engage in cartel collusion. Indeed there is so much transparency in this sector that it must be practically impossible to exaggerate any substantial cost element. Essentially a certain number of bus miles will be driven according to a specific timetable with only one driver on each bus. The main cost items are staff and fuel, both of which can be estimated with considerable precision, and so on. Ticket revenues in the Helsinki Metropolitan Area are processed through a centralised ticketing system operated by the local authorities that license the bus routes. Even advertising revenues are predictable. If you can find scope for profiteering in this system, then you are a genius.

    I should add that for many immigrants having a stable and fair-minded employer is already an asset in itself. There are already enough problems in other areas of immigrant life, and not having to worry about the world of work and relations with the employer is a considerable relief.

    Reply
  26. Mark says:
    October 28, 2011 at 5:49 am

    Johnny

    Stop being such a wimp!

    – “The bus companies, in my opinion, are exploiting the situation and can get away with paying too little for a job which is demanding…And this is bad because…? Am I “slurring” immigrants or making injust generalizations here in your opinion?

    Actually, that’s not what you said. You said, and I quote:

    – “The bus companies are trying to find cheap labor and immigrants are often just that.”

    While on the surface this statement seems quite reasonable, it actually perpetuates a false sense of the situation. Wages are not negotiated by migrants who are being held over a barrel – they are being negotiated by tough unions looking out for the interests of their members. It’s just that simple and JD pulled you up on it. It’s not a huge error on your part, but you made it into a much bigger thing by not conceding the point and confusing it by saying your point was actually something else. Hence your long list.

    Actually, I think you were contributing something useful to the debate, even if you weren’t entirely accurate on some points. But hey, if being pulled up on an argument or being teased in a fairly light-hearted manner causes you such palpitations, then perhaps this ‘bear pit’ isn’t the place for you to massage your opinions.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read more about documentary film
Read more

Recent Posts

  • A promising result about the Perussuomalaiset
  • Reijä Härkönen: Kokoomuksen valtuustoryhmässä Helsingissä on rasisteja
  • It’s the elephant in the room, stupid!
  • The cyanide capsule of the authoritarian ruler
  • (Finland Bridge 1998): Talking to others faraway

Recent Comments

  1. Ahti Tolvanen on Europe is toothless and lost
  2. Ahti Tolvanen on Helsinki Noir: A play reflecting troubled times
  3. JTM on If you went back 200 generations, how many grandparents would you have?
  4. Angel Barrientos on Angel Barrientos is one of the kind beacons of Finland’s Chilean community
  5. Jorge Serendero on Angel Barrientos is one of the kind beacons of Finland’s Chilean community

Archives

  • May 2025
  • April 2025
  • March 2025
  • February 2025
  • January 2025
  • December 2024
  • November 2024
  • October 2024
  • September 2024
  • August 2024
  • July 2024
  • June 2024
  • May 2024
  • April 2024
  • March 2024
  • February 2024
  • January 2024
  • December 2023
  • November 2023
  • October 2023
  • September 2023
  • August 2023
  • July 2023
  • June 2023
  • May 2023
  • April 2023
  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • September 2022
  • August 2022
  • July 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022
  • December 2021
  • November 2021
  • October 2021
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • July 2021
  • June 2021
  • May 2021
  • April 2021
  • March 2021
  • February 2021
  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • August 2020
  • July 2020
  • June 2020
  • May 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • December 2019
  • November 2019
  • October 2019
  • September 2019
  • August 2019
  • July 2019
  • June 2019
  • May 2019
  • April 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • January 2019
  • December 2018
  • November 2018
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • June 2018
  • May 2018
  • April 2018
  • March 2018
  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • December 2017
  • November 2017
  • October 2017
  • September 2017
  • August 2017
  • July 2017
  • June 2017
  • May 2017
  • April 2017
  • March 2017
  • February 2017
  • January 2017
  • December 2016
  • November 2016
  • October 2016
  • September 2016
  • August 2016
  • July 2016
  • June 2016
  • May 2016
  • April 2016
  • March 2016
  • February 2016
  • January 2016
  • December 2015
  • November 2015
  • October 2015
  • September 2015
  • August 2015
  • July 2015
  • June 2015
  • May 2015
  • April 2015
  • March 2015
  • February 2015
  • January 2015
  • December 2014
  • November 2014
  • October 2014
  • September 2014
  • August 2014
  • July 2014
  • June 2014
  • May 2014
  • April 2014
  • March 2014
  • February 2014
  • January 2014
  • December 2013
  • November 2013
  • October 2013
  • September 2013
  • August 2013
  • July 2013
  • June 2013
  • May 2013
  • April 2013
  • March 2013
  • February 2013
  • January 2013
  • December 2012
  • November 2012
  • October 2012
  • September 2012
  • August 2012
  • July 2012
  • June 2012
  • May 2012
  • April 2012
  • March 2012
  • February 2012
  • January 2012
  • December 2011
  • November 2011
  • October 2011
  • September 2011
  • August 2011
  • July 2011
  • June 2011
  • May 2011
  • April 2011
  • March 2011
  • February 2011
  • January 2011
  • December 2010
  • November 2010
  • October 2010
  • September 2010
  • August 2010
  • July 2010
  • June 2010
  • May 2010
  • April 2010
  • March 2010
  • February 2010
  • January 2010
  • December 2009
  • November 2009
  • October 2009
  • September 2009
  • August 2009
  • July 2009
  • December 2008
  • November 2008
  • October 2008
  • September 2008
  • August 2008
  • July 2008
  • June 2008
  • May 2008
  • April 2008
  • March 2008
  • February 2008
  • January 2008
  • November 2007
  • October 2007
  • September 2007
  • August 2007
  • July 2007
  • June 2007
  • May 2007

Categories

  • ?? Gia L?c
  • ????? ?????? ????? ???????? ?? ??????
  • ???????
  • @HerraAhmed
  • @mondepasrond
  • @nohatefinland
  • @oula_silver
  • @Varathas
  • A Pakistani family
  • äärioikeisto
  • Abbas Bahmanpour
  • Abdi Muhis
  • Abdirahim Hussein Mohamed
  • Abdirahim Husu Hussein
  • Abdirisak Mahamed
  • About Migrant Tales
  • activism
  • Adam Al-Sawad
  • Adel Abidin
  • Afrofinland
  • Ahmed IJ
  • Ahti Tolvanen
  • Aino Pennanen
  • Aisha Maniar
  • Alan Ali
  • Alan Anstead
  • Alejandro Díaz Ortiz
  • Alekey Bulavsev
  • Aleksander Hemon
  • Aleksanterinliitto
  • Aleksanterinliitto ry
  • Aleksanterinliitto ry:n hallitus
  • Alex Alex
  • Alex Mckie
  • Alexander Nix
  • Alexandra Ayse Albayrak
  • Alexis Neuberg
  • Ali Asaad Hasan Alzuhairi
  • Ali Hossein Mir Ali
  • Ali Rashid
  • Ali Sagal Abdikarim
  • Alina Tsui
  • Aline Müller
  • All categories
  • Aman Heidari
  • Amiirah Salleh-Hoddin & Jana Turk
  • Amin A. Alem
  • Amir Zuhairi
  • Amkelwa Mbekeni
  • Ana María Gutiérrez Sorainen
  • Anachoma
  • Anders Adlecreutz
  • Angeliina Koskinen
  • Anna De Mutiis
  • Anna María Gutiérrez Sorainen
  • Anna-Kaisa Kuusisto ja Jaakko Tuominen
  • Annastiina Kallius
  • Anneli Juise Friman Lindeman
  • Announcement
  • Anonymous
  • Antero Leitzinger
  • anti-black racism
  • Anti-Hate Crime Organisation Finland
  • Anudari Boldbaatar
  • Aspergers Syndrome
  • Asylum Corner
  • Asylum seeker 406
  • Athena Griffin and Joe Feagin
  • Autism
  • Avaaz.org
  • Awale Olad
  • Ayan Said Mohamed
  • AYY
  • Barachiel
  • Bashy Quraishy
  • Beatrice Kabutakapua
  • Beri Jamal
  • Beri Jamal and Enrique Tessieri
  • Bertolt Brecht
  • Boiata
  • Boodi Kabbani
  • Bruno Gronow
  • Camtu Suhonen
  • Carmen Pekkarinen
  • Çelen Oben and Sheila Riikonen
  • Chiara Costa-Virtanen
  • Chiara Costa-Virtanen
  • Chiara Sorbello
  • Christian Thibault
  • Christopher Wylie
  • Clara Dublanc
  • Dana
  • Daniel Malpica
  • Danilo Canguçu
  • David Papineau
  • David Schneider
  • Dexter He
  • Don Flynn
  • Dr Masoud Kamali
  • Dr. Faith Mkwesha
  • Dr. Theodoros Fouskas
  • Edna Chun
  • Eeva Kilpi
  • Emanuela Susheela
  • En castellano
  • ENAR
  • Enrique
  • Enrique Tessieri
  • Enrique Tessieri & Raghad Mchawh
  • Enrique Tessieri & Yahya Rouissi
  • Enrique Tessieri and Muhammed Shire
  • Enrique Tessieri and Sira Moksi
  • Enrique Tessieri and Tom Vandenbosch
  • Enrique Tessieri and Wael Che
  • Enrique Tessieri and Yahya Rouissi
  • Enrique Tessieri and Zimema Mhone
  • Epäluottamusmies
  • EU
  • Europe
  • European Islamophobia Report
  • European Islamophobia Report 2019,
  • European Union
  • Eve Kyntäjä
  • Facebook
  • Fadumo Dayib
  • Faisa Kahiye
  • Farhad Manjoo
  • Fasismi
  • Finland
  • Fizza Qureshi
  • Flyktingar och asyl
  • Foreign Student
  • Fozia Mir-Ali
  • Frances Webber
  • Frida Selim
  • Gareth Rice
  • Ghyslain Vedeaux
  • Global Art Point
  • Great Replacement
  • Habiba Ali
  • Hami Bahadori
  • Hami Bahdori
  • Hamid
  • Hamid Alsaameere
  • Hamid Bahdori
  • Handshake
  • Harmit Athwal
  • Hassan Abdi Ali
  • Hassan Muhumud
  • Heikki Huttunen
  • Heikki Wilenius
  • Helsingin Sanomat
  • Henning van der Hoeven
  • Henrika Mälmsröm
  • Hser Hser
  • Hser Hser ja Mustafa Isman
  • Husein Muhammed
  • Hussain Kazemian
  • Hussain Kazmenian
  • Ibrahim Khan
  • Ida
  • Ignacio Pérez Pérez
  • Iise Ali Hassan
  • Ilari Kaila & Tuomas Kaila
  • Imam Ka
  • inside-an-airport
  • Institute of Race Relations
  • Iraqi asylum seeker
  • IRR European News Team
  • IRR News Team
  • Islamic Society of Norhern FInland
  • Islamic Society of Northern Finland
  • Islamophobia
  • Jacobinmag.com
  • Jallow Momodou
  • Jan Holmberg
  • Jane Elliott
  • Jani Mäkelä
  • Jari Luoto
  • Jegor Nazarov
  • Jenni Stammeier
  • Jenny Bourne
  • Jessie Daniels
  • Joe Davidow
  • Johannes Koski
  • John D. Foster
  • John Grayson
  • John Marriott
  • Jon Burnett
  • Jorma Härkönen
  • Jos Schuurmans
  • José León Toro Mejías
  • Josue Tumayine
  • Jouni Karnasaari
  • Juan Camilo
  • Jukka Eräkare
  • Julian Abagond
  • Julie Pascoet
  • Jussi Halla-aho
  • Jussi Hallla-aho
  • Jussi Jalonen
  • JusticeDemon
  • Kadar Gelle
  • Kaksoiskansalaisuus
  • Kansainvälinen Mikkeli
  • Kansainvälinen Mikkeli ry
  • Katherine Tonkiss
  • Kati Lepistö
  • Kati van der Hoeven-Lepistö
  • Katie Bell
  • Kättely
  • Kerstin Ögård
  • Keshia Fredua-Mensah & Jamie Schearer
  • Khadidiatou Sylla
  • Khadra Abdirazak Sugulle
  • Kiihotus kansanryhmää vastaan
  • Kirsi Crowley
  • Koko Hubara
  • Kristiina Toivikko
  • Kubra Amini
  • KuRI
  • La Colectiva
  • La incitación al odio
  • Laura Huhtasaari
  • Lauri Finér
  • Leif Hagert
  • Léo Custódio
  • Leo Honka
  • Leontios Christodoulou
  • Lessie Branch
  • Lex Gaudius
  • Leyes de Finlandia
  • Liikkukaa!
  • Linda Hyökki
  • Liz Fekete
  • M. Blanc
  • Maarit Snellman
  • Mahad Sheikh Musse
  • Maija Vilkkumaa
  • Malmin Kebab Pizzeria Port Arthur
  • Marcell Lorincz
  • Mari Aaltola
  • María Paz López
  • Maria Rittis Ikola
  • Maria Tjader
  • Marja-Liisa Tolvanen
  • Mark
  • Markku Heikkinen
  • Marshall Niles
  • Martin Al-Laji
  • Maryan Siyad
  • Matt Carr
  • Mauricio Farah Gebara
  • Media Monitoring Group of Finland
  • Micah J. Christian
  • Michael McEachrane
  • Michele Levoy
  • Michelle Kaila
  • Migrant Tales
  • Migrant Tales Literary
  • Migrantes News
  • Migrants' Rights Network
  • MigriLeaks
  • Mikko Kapanen
  • Miriam Attias and Camila Haavisto
  • Mohamed Adan
  • Mohammad Javid
  • Mohammad M.
  • Monikulttuurisuus
  • Monisha Bhatia and Victoria Canning
  • Mor Ndiaye
  • Muh'ed
  • Muhamed Abdimajed Murshid
  • Muhammed Shire
  • Muhammed Shire and Enrique Tessieri
  • Muhis Azizi
  • Musimenta Dansila
  • Muslimiviha
  • Musulmanes
  • Namir al-Azzawi
  • Natsismi
  • Neurodiversity
  • New Women Connectors
  • Nils Muižnieks
  • No Labels No Walls
  • Noel Dandes
  • Nuor Dawood
  • Omar Khan
  • Otavanmedia
  • Oula Silvennoinen
  • Paco Diop
  • Pakistani family
  • Pentti Stranius
  • Perussuomalaiset
  • perustuslaki
  • Petra Laiti
  • Petri Cederlöf
  • Pia Grochowski
  • Podcast-lukija Bea Bergholm
  • Pohjois – Suomen Islamilainen Yhdyskunta
  • Pohjois Suomen Islamilainen Yhyskunta
  • Polina Kopylova
  • Race Files
  • racism
  • Racism Review
  • Raghad Mchawh
  • Ranska
  • Rashid H. and Migrant Tales
  • Rasismi
  • Raul Perez
  • Rebecka Holm
  • Reem Abu-Hayyeh
  • Refugees
  • Reija Härkönen
  • Remiel
  • Reza Nasri
  • Richard Gresswell
  • Riikka Purra
  • Risto Laakkonen
  • Rita Chahda
  • Ritva Kondi
  • Robito Ibrahim
  • Roble Bashir
  • Rockhaya Sylla
  • Rodolfo Walsh
  • Roger Casale
  • Rostam Atai
  • Roxana Crisólogo Correa
  • Ruth Grove-White
  • Ruth Waweru-Folabit
  • S-worldview
  • Sadio Ali Nuur
  • Sandhu Bhamra
  • Sara de Jong
  • Sarah Crowther
  • Sari Alhariri
  • Sarkawt Khalil
  • Sasu
  • Scot Nakagawa
  • Shabana Ahmadzai
  • Shada Islam
  • Sharon Chang blogs
  • Shenita Ann McLean
  • Shirlene Green Newball
  • Sini Savolainen
  • Sira Moksi
  • Sonia K.
  • Sonia Maria Koo
  • Steverp
  • Stop Deportations
  • Suldaan Said Ahmed
  • Suomen mediaseurantakollektiivi
  • Suomen Muslimifoorumi ry
  • Suomen viharikosvastainen yhdistys
  • Suomen viharikosvastainen yhdistys ry
  • Suomi
  • Supermen
  • Susannah
  • Suva
  • Syrjintä
  • Talous
  • Tapio Tuomala
  • Taw Reh
  • Teivo Teivainen
  • The Daily Show
  • The Heino
  • The Supermen
  • Thomas Elfgren
  • Thulfiqar Abdulkarim
  • Tim McGettigan
  • Tino Singh
  • Tito Moustafa Sliem
  • Tobias Hübinette and L. Janelle Dance
  • Transport
  • Trica Danielle Keaton
  • Trilce Garcia
  • Trish Pääkkönen
  • Trish Pääkkönen and Enrique Tessieri
  • Tuulia Reponen
  • Uncategorized
  • UNITED
  • University of Eastern Finland
  • Uyi Osazee
  • Väkivalta
  • Venla-Sofia Saariaho
  • Vieraskynä
  • W. Che
  • W. Che an Enrique Tessieri
  • Wael Ch.
  • Wan Wei
  • Women for Refugee Women
  • Xaan Kaafi Maxamed Xalane
  • Xassan Kaafi Maxamed Xalane
  • Xassan-Kaafi Mohamed Halane & Enrique Tessieri
  • Yahya Rouissi
  • Yasmin Yusuf
  • Yassen Ghaleb
  • Yle Puhe
  • Yve Shepherd
  • Zahra Khavari
  • Zaker
  • Zamzam Ahmed Ali
  • Zeinab Amini ja Soheila Khavari
  • Zimema Mahone and Enrique Tessieri
  • Zimema Mhone
  • Zoila Forss Crespo Moreyra
  • ZT
  • Zulma Sierra
  • Zuzeeko Tegha Abeng
© 2025 Migrant tales | Powered by Minimalist Blog WordPress Theme